Watch this interview on YouTube.
In this Monday Market Minute, D.J. Paris talks with Carrie McCormick, a top-producing luxury agent with @properties Christie’s International Real Estate in Chicago. She tells how a celebrity client found her through ChatGPT and how answering her phone led to a $9.5 million listing opportunity, then walks through a $6 million deal she saved when the buyer got cold feet.
What you’ll learn
- Answer your phone. A New York number turned out to be a client who asked ChatGPT for the top agent in Chicago and was surprised that Carrie picked up. (06:06)
- Know your buyer’s psychology. Carrie does her own showings, which helps her read how a buyer thinks before negotiations start. (09:36)
- Don’t react right away to a late-night call. When the buyer’s agent called with cold feet, Carrie slept on it, weighed salvaging the deal against moving to a backup buyer, and set up a call for the next morning. (12:09)
- Separate the noise from the house. She acknowledged the buyer’s worry, then reframed the decision around a property that could not be replaced. (14:05)
- Keep the backup buyer informed, with care. She talked quietly with the second buyer so she had options without pushing the listing back onto the market. (16:36)
- Empathy and a clear plan won the deal. The buyers moved forward at a strong price with no concessions and told her she had spoken in a human way. (18:28)
“Because the noise in the market to me is very temporary. The house is forever.”
Carrie McCormick (at 14:32)
Chapters
00:00 Intro
03:06 Meet Carrie McCormick
04:58 Why top producers answer their phone
06:06 The celebrity client who found her through ChatGPT
08:19 The story: a $6 million luxury listing
10:19 The late-night call: the buyer gets cold feet
12:09 Two paths: save the deal or pivot to buyer two
13:25 The call with the buyer
16:36 Talking with the backup buyer
17:45 The decision
19:07 What she learned about doing the right thing
20:18 Wrap-up and how to reach Carrie
Links from this episode
- Carrie McCormick’s website: carriemccormickre.com
- Carrie on Instagram
Listen and follow
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or YouTube. Follow the show on Instagram, Facebook and LinkedIn.
This episode is brought to you by Real Geeks and Courted.io.
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | SpotifyRead the full transcript
Transcript
[00:00:00] Top agents do whatever it takes to help their clients make the best possible decisions around real estate.
[00:00:06] Today, Karen McCormick is going to share with us a story when she reached out to the client on the
[00:00:11] other side of the deal to help them and saved the day. Stay tuned.
[00:00:16] This episode of Keeping It Real is brought to you by Real Geeks. How many homes are you going to
[00:00:21] sell this year? Do you have the right tools? Is your website turning soft leads and interested
[00:00:26] buyers? Are you spending money on leads that aren't converting? Well, Real Geeks is your solution.
[00:00:32] Find out why agents across the country choose Real Geeks as their technology partner.
[00:00:37] Real Geeks was created by an agent for agents. They pride themselves on delivering a sales and
[00:00:42] marketing solution so that you can easily generate more business. Their agent websites are fast and
[00:00:48] built for lead conversion with a smooth search experience for your visitors. Real Geeks also
[00:00:54] includes an easy to use agent CRM. So once a lead signs up on your website, you can track their
[00:01:01] interests and have great follow up conversations. Real Geeks is loaded with a ton of marketing tools
[00:01:06] to nurture your leads and increase brand awareness. Visit realgeeks.com forward slash Keeping It Real
[00:01:13] Pod and find out why REALTORS come to Real Geeks to generate more business. Again, visit realgeeks.com
[00:01:19] forward slash Keeping It Real Pod. And now onto our show.
[00:01:24] Today's episode is brought to you by corded.io. Are you looking for agents to join your brokerage
[00:01:30] or team? Now as a real estate recruiter, I can tell you the answer is always yes. But most agents
[00:01:37] aren't looking to move right now. So how do you know who to contact? Well, what if I were to tell
[00:01:41] you there's a recruiting and retention tool powered by artificial intelligence that shows you
[00:01:46] exactly which agents in your local market are looking to leave their brokerage right now and
[00:01:52] which agents at your own firm are also looking to leave you. Now I've been recruiting REALTORS for
[00:01:58] 15 years and I've hired over 2000 agents. I can tell you with no exaggeration, this is the tool
[00:02:04] I've been waiting for. Corded's AI looks for trends across dozens of variables for each agent in
[00:02:10] your market and shows you which agents they believe are likely to move. Not only does it do that,
[00:02:15] but corded's AI went and visited my recruiting website and read everything I offer. So now when I'm
[00:02:21] recruiting, corded's AI tells me exactly what to say based on that agent's needs and what my brokerage
[00:02:28] can offer. It even writes emails for me. I've never seen anything like it and I use it every single day.
[00:02:34] Now if you are looking to grow your brokerage corded.io is the best tool out there. Visit corded.io
[00:02:41] to schedule a demo again. That's corded.io and now onto the show.
[00:03:00] Right, welcome back. This is the Keeping It Real podcast. My name is DJ Paris. I am your guide and
[00:03:06] host of the show. We are the largest podcast made for real estate agents and for real estate agents
[00:03:11] today is our Monday market minute with Carrie McCormick. We do this monthly. Carrie is one of the top
[00:03:17] top top agents here in Chicago land and Ashley all over the country, but she works here in Chicago
[00:03:24] land area. So if you don't know who carries, she's with at properties, Christie's International
[00:03:28] Real Estate here in Chicago. She is consistently ranked in the top 1% of all Chicago REALTORS. In fact,
[00:03:34] in 2025, she and her team closed and basically her closed 327 million for her highest year ever.
[00:03:42] And she's crushing it this year as well. She is doing this for 24 years. She sold over a billion
[00:03:49] dollars in real estate and specializes in like 3.5 billion. I am so so that's how bad my data is
[00:03:57] 3.5 billion. I think I say 1 billion doesn't sound right. 3.5 billion in Chicago real estate,
[00:04:03] specializing in luxury properties from Lincoln Park to Gold Coast to North Shore. She actually
[00:04:08] is everywhere. Chicago magazine, Housing Wire, everybody knows who Carrie is. She gets lots of
[00:04:13] articles written about her and she's on lots of podcasts and gets interviewed. Today, Carrie is
[00:04:18] going to share a share a story with us about how she turns things around for clients or we thought
[00:04:25] it would be really fun for her to share some of her war stories with us. And so Carrie, welcome back
[00:04:30] to the show. Oh, thank you. And let's have everybody follow you. Carrie McCormick, RE,
[00:04:36] at his Instagram. So follow her. She does the most amazing social media videos for her listings,
[00:04:44] for herself. She is just, it's amazing the the amount of time and you do it all yourself. It's
[00:04:54] a lot of fun, right? You love what you do and you don't work a day in your life.
[00:04:58] Yes. And you know what I you know it's funny. I just made a video. I started making my own
[00:05:03] little social media 30-second videos with a like a tip of the day. And I didn't reference you
[00:05:08] specifically, but I wanted to mention that you fall into this category. I just did one that said,
[00:05:13] one thing that top 1% producers like you do that a lot of agents who are not at that level don't
[00:05:20] realize. And it's sort of sort of counterintuitive is you answer your phone. And you think that you'd
[00:05:26] be way too busy to answer your phone and you sort of are, but you still do it. And because
[00:05:32] and every top 1% producer I know does the same thing. So it's kind of funny. People think that they
[00:05:37] once they get to this level, like they got this whole team of assistants. I know you have people
[00:05:41] that that help out, but you're the one talking to clients. You're the one doing all the the
[00:05:46] grunt work. So I just think like agents it's crazy when agents don't answer their phone is what I
[00:05:52] say. Yeah, you know actually to that point, it was not yesterday, but the day before I do try to
[00:05:59] answer my phone every you know every time it rings. But I got a call from somebody. It was a New
[00:06:06] York number. And you know there's a lot of spam calls going on right now, but I did pick up. And
[00:06:13] it was kind of a celebrity client, which I can't say. And he said his name and
[00:06:21] you know I'm listening to you know we're talking and I asked him how he found me. And this is
[00:06:26] kind of fun. He said he asked Chad GPT. You're kidding. Because he doesn't live here anymore. He
[00:06:32] has a property here, but he doesn't live here anymore. And he hasn't been here for a few years. And
[00:06:36] he said you know who is the top real estate agent in Chicago. And he was specific about what he was
[00:06:40] looking for. He had periods of what he wanted. And he said that Chad came up with a top four
[00:06:47] recommendation. And then he asked Chad, he said out of the four, you know based on who I am,
[00:06:53] what I need, what my criteria is. This is what he wanted from service. He said who would you
[00:06:58] recommend? And he said it was me. And I'm like oh my gosh, you have to send me that. I want to see
[00:07:03] it, you know, and he did. He's kind of excited and sent it to me. So it was kind of funny to see
[00:07:08] number one, you know how people are searching for real estate agents. And two, you know I came up
[00:07:14] and number three, which is the most important part is I answered the phone. You know, he said that.
[00:07:20] He's like, oh, he's like, I didn't expect you to answer. And I said, well, of course I'm an
[00:07:25] answer. And he's like, I just didn't expect that. Not, I mean, he's very important, but you know,
[00:07:29] I just, I think he just didn't expect me to answer the phone. So we'll end especially
[00:07:34] on the 9.5 million dollar listing here soon, guys. Wow. From that one call.
[00:07:39] Unbelievable. And this is somebody that could have asked his manager, his agent, whoever,
[00:07:47] you know, he's his people. He could have outsourced that to someone else. He didn't.
[00:07:53] And then he made the call directly, which I talked to a ton of luxury agents in your space,
[00:07:59] especially the ones out West and in Hollywood. They oftentimes don't get the call from the client.
[00:08:06] They get the call from the team. And, and so the fact that he even called you is amazing. And
[00:08:11] that you saw, well, this is New York is probably a spam call. When I see a New York phone call,
[00:08:14] come in, I assume it's spam. I don't even answer it. The fact that you answered it just got you a
[00:08:19] great, great deal. So amazing. Wow. And Chatsy PT thinks you're pretty great, too. That's another
[00:08:25] great thing. I don't know how that happened, but that's great. All right. Let's do it. I know
[00:08:29] you're busy. Let's get into it. The storytelling is always a great, I think it's great and
[00:08:36] very important in our business. And, you know, I just ran into a situation and I thought back
[00:08:41] through it. I think this is a good platform to talk through it, too, with the audience of just
[00:08:46] what happened. So this is one of those deals where if you blink, it's gone, right? It's managing
[00:08:54] the expectations of a deal all the way through. So here's, here's a story. Let me just, I'm going to
[00:08:59] try to put it in a timeline that makes sense. So I was representing a luxury seller here in Chicago.
[00:09:07] It was properties about $6 million. So when Chicago, that's a luxury home. It was a great location,
[00:09:14] beautifully designed home. We launched it into the market perfectly. Very strong interest
[00:09:21] out the gate. And within several days, a serious buyer emerged. Okay. So everything was on par.
[00:09:30] This buyer, because I do all my showings, which is a great way to meet the buyers, get to know the
[00:09:36] buyers. They were highly analytical, very successful people. Didn't have a lot of time in their day.
[00:09:44] So they wanted service. They wanted time. Very straight data. It's a type of client who does not
[00:09:53] make emotional decisions. And you could tell that with meeting this person. So again, part of our
[00:09:58] job is being a real estate agent for our sellers is getting to know who the buyer is. Because once
[00:10:05] you start negotiating with this person, you need to understand their psychology as well. So
[00:10:14] we had it on terms that worked for both sides. And we were quickly under contract. Everything was
[00:10:19] solid. Everything was smooth. And we all know in these deals. It's smooth until it's not smooth.
[00:10:26] Right. So here's where the problem came in. We entered here in Illinois. We have attorney review.
[00:10:31] So we entered into attorney review. It was three days into our attorney review. I get a call late
[00:10:38] at night. And of course, we all know that when we get that phone call at 930 at night from the
[00:10:43] opposing broker, you know, it's, you know, your heart sends. That is. It's not usually good news
[00:10:51] when it's that late of a call, right? And especially knowing the tone of the broker of like,
[00:10:56] hi, you know, like versus hi, I have a question. So it's, you know, that tone. And I'm like,
[00:11:03] what's going on? And she said my buyer's getting cold feet. And it wasn't because of the home,
[00:11:12] you know, I asked, you know, what's going on? And it wasn't because of the house itself. It was
[00:11:16] because of the volatility of the market, right? We know there's a lot happening in the world right now.
[00:11:21] And what happens outside of real estate, politics, stock market, all that fun stuff, you know,
[00:11:27] it does affect people's psychology, right? So it wasn't because of the home, it was because of
[00:11:33] the market. They've been watching the headlines, the volatility of the market started questioning,
[00:11:38] is this the right time to deploy capital out of the market right now, right? As the market's plummeting,
[00:11:44] you know, do I do this? So she says to me, the broker says to me, you know, they're, they want to
[00:11:51] sleep on it, but they're really reconsidering moving forward. So of course, you know, thanks for that
[00:11:59] 9.30 PM call the night before, or you know, and so I can't sleep that night. But at the same time,
[00:12:04] there was another interested party in this house who had missed out, you know, we went under
[00:12:09] contracts so quickly. I know that I kind of have a plan B in my pocket. So I thought about it
[00:12:17] overnight. I'm like, I have two paths forward. Number one, I could try to salvage the deal that I have
[00:12:22] in place, right? The person that's reconsidering and losing confidence in the market, or do I pivot
[00:12:30] to this other buyer, the second buyer and push buyer one out, right? So here's the, here's the
[00:12:38] real reality of this is I'm marked contingent in our MLS, right? Which means we're under contract.
[00:12:45] If the first deal dies, I may have to reactivate the listing. So now that's publicly, you know,
[00:12:53] showing the house was on, went off, was back on, and you know how that looks in the market.
[00:12:57] Right. People go, what happened? What's wrong with this place?
[00:13:00] Along with it, you lose leverage instantly when that happens, right? And then now you've got to
[00:13:06] start explaining what happened. So, and then, so here's the strategy in this scenario. And this is
[00:13:13] where most deals fall apart because people react very quickly, right? And I've learned through all
[00:13:18] my years is I'm a very decisive person. I know how to make good decisions, but there are times where
[00:13:25] you need to step back for a moment and really kind of think through it, right? And not react quickly.
[00:13:31] So instead, I scheduled a call for the following morning and I said, can we have your buyer on the
[00:13:38] phone? Which is not usual, right? And when we talk broker to broker. But I just said, you know, I
[00:13:47] just would love to have a conversation. All of us together, let's kind of talk through what's
[00:13:52] going on so we can resolve this. And so, to my surprise, the broker agreed to this. So,
[00:13:57] we had a call and I was very confident in my in my tone in the call, right? And I had all my
[00:14:05] ducks in a row and I was writing for this call and I said to the buyer that I completely understand
[00:14:09] your hesitation. So, acknowledging, you know, that push back at how they're feeling. And I
[00:14:16] acknowledged that they're making a significant investment in this property and you should question it.
[00:14:21] I mean, it's it's human nature. The world's falling apart on this side, you know, I totally get it.
[00:14:27] But let's think this through logically. Let's separate the noise of the market from the acid of
[00:14:32] the home, right? Because the noise in the market to me is very temporary. The house is forever. So,
[00:14:42] this isn't a market timing decision. It's an opportunity to secure this particular property
[00:14:48] that would not can cannot be replaced. I mean, it's not a cookie cutter home. It's a very unique
[00:14:54] property. Cannot be replicated in today's market. And then I showed them or spoke to them really
[00:15:01] about the market. There's no there's no inventory. There's a few homes that are trading at this
[00:15:09] level. And I said to them very directly and respectfully, if you walk away from this home,
[00:15:17] I completely respect you. But I want you to be very clear. You're not you're passing on a moment
[00:15:23] of time. No, you're not passing on a moment in time. You're passing on a property that you'll never
[00:15:29] see in the market again. This is a one of a kind. It's a friend. And again, my tone was very
[00:15:35] direct. It was empathetic too, right? Because, you know, I think having empathy in this market does
[00:15:41] matter. Having candid conversations with people matter. And then I hung up and I, well, I said before
[00:15:47] I hung up, I said, there's no pressure, you know, but I want you to think about how you're making
[00:15:53] this decision. You know, you're, I think it's an emotional decision. You don't put the market into
[00:15:58] this. That'll pass. The market's going to swing back, which it already is. Market meaning like
[00:16:02] stock market, etc. But this one home for you and your family is a one of a kind opportunity.
[00:16:09] Irreplaceable. You have it right now. Don't walk away from this opportunity. No pressure. You know,
[00:16:15] I want you to think about it. I'm here when you're ready, but completely understand your decision. So
[00:16:21] okay, so that happens, right? And then at the same time, remember, I have this other buyer in my pocket,
[00:16:27] I quietly go over to buyer number two and have a strategic conversation with them too. And I said
[00:16:36] there might be another opportunity for this home, right? There is timing is going to matter on this,
[00:16:43] you know, because again, if buyer number two wants to wants the property, you know, they will have
[00:16:49] to pivot very quickly because I didn't want to market contingent. I didn't want to do do all that.
[00:16:54] So now I have leverage. I've got buyer number one who's already under contract. Great conversation
[00:17:00] with them. Buy your number two, not blasting it out. I'm just having a real conversation with them
[00:17:06] as well. And kind of let both parties sit on it. So at this point to me, I've got the leverage.
[00:17:13] I've got two buyers, you know, sitting here. But again, you have to balance this very carefully,
[00:17:18] because you don't want to also walk away with nothing. Right. Both could fall apart. Yeah. Both of them
[00:17:23] can call it, call apart. So a day had passed, which again, and we all know being in this situation,
[00:17:29] time kills a deal, right? And you're like, what's going on? What are they thinking through?
[00:17:35] It was actually the following morning I got the call from the broker again, bright and early,
[00:17:40] heart starts beating a little bit, you know, like here's the decision. And she says to me, and again,
[00:17:45] tone of voice always matters. I always am a good listener. And she says, good morning.
[00:17:53] Like, oh, God, I know, you know, kind of like, what is this? And she said, my clients thought it
[00:18:00] through. And it's like that slow tone, right? I'm like, just tell me what it is. My clients have
[00:18:06] thought it through, Carrie. They really appreciate your call. They really do. And they want to move
[00:18:12] forward because they think you're right. This is an incredible asset that they don't want to pass up.
[00:18:17] Amazing. You know, so it was a really great success story. We lacked in the deal. It was strong price.
[00:18:28] No concessions in this deal. And we went through the inspection of the home. And the buyers came to
[00:18:34] me and they said, you know, we really appreciate we felt that you, we know you represent the seller,
[00:18:40] Carrie. We know that. But the way that you spoke to us was so human. And I don't know if they
[00:18:47] used the word empathetic, but they felt that, right? They felt that there was care. And,
[00:18:53] you know, but really, to me, it was, I always do care, but I was very strategic about the words I
[00:18:59] used, my tone that I used, how I phrased it. And it really, again, the buyer acknowledging that
[00:19:07] the sad part of the story is buyer number two was so excited because they thought they had an
[00:19:11] opportunity. So I had to call them and say that, you know, buyer number one was pulling through. And,
[00:19:16] you know, if something changes, I'll let them know. But, you know, the second agent was appreciative
[00:19:22] that I did reach out to them before I, you know, pushed it public. So again, it's, it's handling
[00:19:28] these, these sticky situations with grace being professional about it and always doing the right
[00:19:35] thing. You always win if you do the right thing. You really treated each party from their point of
[00:19:41] view and thought, what do they need? How can I serve them? Even though you're representing the
[00:19:47] seller from a fiduciary perspective, you're still serving the buyer client with their emotional needs.
[00:19:54] You're, it's authentic. It's honest. Yeah, that's all people really want is and you, you validated
[00:20:00] that. You said, yes, I completely get it. This is a big deal. And, and there's a lot of noise out
[00:20:06] there that will, you know, make people think twice about any big decision. That's awesome. And
[00:20:13] what a great story. So I think that's a wonderful place to wrap up. I think everyone listening
[00:20:18] probably took something away from that and please consider doing that in every deal. Treat every
[00:20:24] deal as if it's the most critical deal and you'll have a great career like Carrie. Also, if you are an
[00:20:30] agent outside the Chicago Land area, most of our listeners and viewers are not from Chicago,
[00:20:35] please consider Carrie, chat GPT chooses Carrie when passing it on to people from outside the area.
[00:20:42] You should consider her as well. If you have a client that is moving in or out of the Chicago
[00:20:47] Land area and she also has people moving in and out of Chicago too. You want to consider
[00:20:52] networking with her. See if you might be a good match. Definitely reach out to her. She's all
[00:20:56] over in social media. Carrie McCormick are ease where you find her on Instagram and Carrie,
[00:21:02] do you want to give out? Sorry, Carrie McCormick real estate, my apologies. And we, by the way,
[00:21:07] we have a link to this in the show notes. So just go there. Carrie McCormick real estate.
[00:21:12] It carried you want to give out your your email as well? Sure, it's Carrie C-A-R-R-I-E
[00:21:20] at atproporties.com or you know I pick up the phone 312-9614-612.
[00:21:27] Thank you to our sponsors. Thank you to Carrie for jumping on. She is, she just pushed a call for
[00:21:32] a few minutes to finish this with us. We appreciate you. We will let you get to that call.
[00:21:36] Thanks on behalf of our audience. Thank you to Carrie and the audience for sticking around.
[00:21:40] Please tell a friend about keeping your real podcast. We appreciate you telling another agent
[00:21:45] about what we do here, sending them a link and helping us continue to grow.
[00:21:49] All right, we will see everybody on the next episode. Thanks, Carrie. Bye, thank you.
Share this episode!
